Discipleship Is Not Abstract Following — It Is Covenant Living, and Covenant Living Is Learning to Walk in God’s Commands as Taught and Fulfilled by Jesus

If following Jesus does not include learning to obey what God actually commands… what does discipleship even mean?

A. Why discipleship is not vague in Scripture

Many Christians speak of “following Jesus” in a warm and sincere way, but often in a way that is still too undefined. Some point to love alone and stop there.

“A new command I give you: love one another as I have loved you.”

That is true—but stopping there creates an incomplete picture. Scripture does not leave discipleship vague.

Matthew 28:18–20 — “Teaching them to observe all that I commanded you.”

Notice the clarity: discipleship is not inspiration—it is instruction and obedience.

Just two days earlier, Jesus said:

Matthew 23:3 — “Do whatever they tell you, and observe it. But don’t do what they do…”

• Jesus affirms obedience to what Moses taught
• But rejects hypocrisy, not the instruction itself

Matthew 23:23 — “These things should have been done without neglecting the others.”

• Jesus affirms both “weightier” and “lesser” commands
• He calls for complete righteousness, not selective obedience

A disciple is someone who learns a Master’s way of life—and then walks in it.

If Jesus commands us to teach others to obey what He taught, then following Him must include concrete obedience. Otherwise, “following Jesus” becomes so vague that it can mean almost anything.

Back to top

B. Why covenant defines relationship with God

In Scripture, relationship with God is never undefined. It is covenantal. God does not merely gather spiritual admirers; He binds a people to Himself.

Covenant is not a vague spiritual bond. It is a defined relationship of belonging, loyalty, and obligation.

This matters because many believers speak of relationship as if relationship and obedience were opposites. But in the Bible, covenant relationship is precisely the context in which obedience makes sense.

• God redeems a people
• God brings them near
• God claims them as His own
• Then God teaches them how to walk as His people

Relationship with God in Scripture is not less than obedience. It is the very reason obedience now matters.

So the issue is not whether covenant matters for discipleship. The issue is whether discipleship can even be understood correctly without covenant.

Back to top

C. Why Torah is instruction, not a vague ideal

Torah is often reduced in Christian discussion to “old law,” as if it were only a burdensome system that existed before grace. But Torah means instruction. It is God’s teaching, God’s revealed way, God’s guidance for how His people are to walk before Him.

Torah is not the opposite of relationship. Torah is the shape of covenant life.

It tells God’s people what holiness looks like, what justice looks like, what love looks like, what worship looks like, and what faithfulness looks like in real life.

• Torah gives form to obedience
• Torah gives content to righteousness
• Torah gives definition to “walking with God”

The better question is not, “Do Christians care about God’s instruction?” The better question is, “How is God’s instruction rightly understood and lived through Christ?”

If discipleship is learning to walk in God’s ways, then Torah cannot be dismissed as though it has nothing to do with that walk.

Back to top

D. How Jesus fulfills the Law without abolishing it

Jesus did not present Himself as a rival to the Father’s commands. He did not come to detach His followers from the moral will of God. He came as the obedient Son, the faithful Israelite, the perfect image of covenant loyalty, and the One who fulfills what the Law and the Prophets were aiming toward.

To say that Jesus fulfills the Law does not mean He makes obedience irrelevant.

It means He embodies its goal, reveals its depth, strips away corrupt interpretations, and shows what true righteousness looks like.

• He does not lead people away from the Father’s ways
• He leads them into their true meaning
• He shows what covenant faithfulness looks like in flesh and blood

Following Jesus and honoring God’s instruction do not compete with each other. In Christ, they belong together.

Back to top

E. Why love does not replace obedience

One of the most common modern Christian ideas is that love replaces commandment-keeping. But biblically, love is not the cancellation of obedience. Love is the right expression of obedience.

Love is not the removal of form; it is the heart that fills God’s commands with sincerity and truth.

When Jesus ties love to keeping His commandments, He destroys the false choice between heartfelt devotion and practical obedience.

• If we love Him, we do not care less about what He says
• We care more about what He says
• Love makes obedience living, personal, grateful, and willing

When Paul says love fulfills the Law, he is not teaching that love makes commandments unnecessary. He is teaching that genuine love walks in the kind of life God’s instruction was always pointing toward.

Back to top

F. Why walking in the Spirit is not lawlessness

Another common mistake is the idea that being led by the Spirit means being free from concern about God’s commands. But the Spirit does not produce rebellion against God’s will.

The Spirit does not create distance from righteousness; the Spirit empowers righteousness.

In Paul’s thinking, the flesh resists God’s law. The Spirit does not.

• The flesh wants autonomy
• The flesh wants self-rule
• The flesh wants selective obedience
• The Spirit leads believers into holiness, faithfulness, self-control, and real conformity to Christ

Walking in the Spirit should never be used as a slogan for ambiguity. It should mean the opposite: a life increasingly brought into agreement with God’s revealed righteousness.

Back to top

G. Grace, salvation, and what obedience is for

This point must stay clear: we are not saved by law-keeping. God’s commands do not cleanse our guilt, raise us from spiritual death, or earn our justification. The blood of Christ saves. Grace saves. The mercy of God saves.

Grace does not rescue us so that we can remain undefined, undisciplined, and lawless.

But Scripture never uses grace to argue that obedience no longer matters.

• Grace rescues us into covenant faithfulness
• Grace reconciles us to God
• Grace begins a new life of walking rightly with Him

Obedience is not the cause of redemption. It is the path of the redeemed.

It is not how we get Christ to love us. It is how those loved by Christ learn to live.

Back to top

H. The clearest way to say the whole point

That statement protects several truths at once.

• It protects grace, because it does not say we are saved by commands
• It protects covenant, because it recognizes that salvation brings us into belonging
• It protects discipleship, because it refuses to leave following Jesus undefined
• It protects Torah, because it recognizes that God has always cared how His people walk

Following Jesus is deeply personal, but it is not undefined. It takes shape in submission, holiness, imitation, and obedience.

Back to top

I. Questions for the reader

These questions are meant to expose how easily modern discipleship becomes vague if it is detached from covenant and obedience.

If following Jesus does not include learning to obey what God actually commands, what does discipleship even mean?

If covenant relationship does not include covenant faithfulness, what kind of covenant is it?

If the Spirit leads us, why would He lead us away from the righteousness God revealed?

If Jesus is Lord, in what sense are we following Him if we do not care how He tells us to walk?

And if grace saves us, should grace not also train us to live as people who now belong to God?

Back to top